What Exactly Is a SLAP Lesion? Top 5 Things You Need to Know About a Superior Labral Tear

Glenoid fossa of right side.I received many great questions and comments regarding my last post discussing two new tests to detect a SLAP tear.  Sounds like there is still a little confusion about what exactly a SLAP tear is and how to classify them.  Understanding how a SLAP lesion occurs and what exactly is happening pathologically is extremely important to diagnose and treat these shoulder injuries appropriately.  Over the next few weeks I will be focusing more on a series of posts dedicated to SLAP injuries and try to relay the most important information and dispel a few myths along the way.  This week will be classification and pathomechanics of SLAP injuries.  (Image via Wikipedia)  
Classification of SLAP Lesions

There are several variations of injuries that can occur to the superior labrum where the biceps anchor attaches (see the above figure to view the biceps attaching into the labrum).  Following a retrospective review of 700 shoulder arthroscopies, Snyder et al: Arthroscopy ’90 identified 4 types of superior labrum lesions involving the biceps anchor.  Collectively they termed these SLAP lesions, in reference to their anatomic location: Superior Labrum extending from Anterior to Posterior.  This was the original definition but as we continue to learn more about SLAP tears, they certainly do not always extend from anterior to posterior.  But, the most important concept to know is that a SLAP lesion is an injury to the superior labrum near the attachment of the biceps anchor.


Type I-IV SLAP lesions from left to right
  • Type I SLAP lesions were described as being indicative of isolated fraying of the superior labrum with a firm attachment of the labrum to the glenoid.  These lesions are typically degenerative in nature.  At this time, it is currently believed that the majority of the active population may have a Type I SLAP lesion and this is often not even considered pathological by many surgeons.
  • Type II SLAP lesions are characterized by a detachment of the superior labrum and the origin of the tendon of the long head of the biceps brachii from the glenoid resulting in instability of the biceps-labral anchor.  These is the most common type of SLAP tear.  When we receive a script from a surgeon to treat a “SLAP repair” he or she is more than likely talking about a Type II SLAP and surgery to re-attach the labrum and biceps anchor.  Three distinct sub-categories of type II SLAP lesions have been further identified by Morgan et al: Arthroscopy ’90.  They reported that in a series of 102 patients undergoing arthroscopic evaluation 37% presented with an anterosuperior lesion, 31% with a posterosuperior lesion, and 31% exhibited a combined anterior and superior lesion. (33)  These findings are consistent with my clinical observations of patients.  Different types of patients and mechanisms of injuries will result in slightly different Type II lesions.  For example, the majority of overhead athletes present with posterosuperior lesions while individuals who have traumatic SLAP lesions typically present with anterosuperior lesions.  These variations are important when selecting which special tests to perform based on the patient’s history and mechanism of injury.  We’ll get to this in a future post on all the different clinical tests for SLAP tears.
  • Type III SLAP lesions are characterized by a bucket-handle tear of the labrum with an intact biceps insertion.  The labrum tears and flips into the joint similar to a meniscus.  The important concept here is that the biceps anchor is attached, unlike a Type II.
  • Type IV SLAP lesions have a bucket-handle tear of the labrum that extends into the biceps tendon.  In this lesion, instability of the biceps-labrum anchor is also present, similar to that seen in the type II SLAP lesion.  This is basically a combination of a Type II and III lesion.
What is complicated about this classification system is the fact that the Type I-IV scale is not progressively more severe.  For example a Type III SLAP lesion is not bigger, or more severe, or indicative to more pathology than a Type II SLAP lesion.
To further complicate things,  Maffet et al: AJSM ’95 noted that 38% of the SLAP lesions identified in their retrospective review of 712 arthroscopies were not classifiable using the I-IV terminology previously defined by Snyder et al (49).  They suggested expanding the classification scale for SLAP lesions to a total of 7 categories, adding descriptions for types V-VII. (29)
  • Type V SLAP lesions are characterized by the presence of a Bankart lesion of the anterior capsule that extends into the anterior superior labrum. 
  • Type VI SLAP lesion involve a disruption of the biceps tendon anchor with an anterior or posterior superior labral flap tear.
  • Type VII SLAP lesions are described as the extension of a SLAP lesion anteriorly to involve the area inferior to the middle glenohumeral ligament. 
These 3 types typically involve a concomitant pathology in conjunction with a SLAP lesion.  Although they provided further classification, this terminology has not caught on and is not frequqntly used.  For example, most people will refer to a Type V SLAP as a Type II SLAP with a concomitant Bankart lesion.  Since then there have been even more classification types described in the literatue, up to at least 10 that I know of, but don’t worry, nobody really uses them.

Top 5 things you need to know about classifying SLAP lesions

  1. Just worry about Type I-IV SLAP lesions and realize that any classification system above Type IV just means that there was a concomitant injury in addition to the SLAP tear.
  2. You can break down and group Type I and Type III lesions together.  Both involved degeneration of the labrum but the biceps anchor is attached.  Thus, these are not unstable SLAP lesions are not surgically repaired.  This makes surgery (just a simple debridement) and physical therapy easier.
  3. You can also break down and group Type II and Type IV lesions togther.  Both involve a detached biceps anchor and require surgery to stabilize the biceps anchor.  Type IV SLAP tears are much more uncommon and will involve the repair and a debridement of the bucket handle tear.
  4. Type II lesions are by far the most common that you will see in the clinic and are almost always what a surgeon is referring to when speaking of a “SLAP repair.”
  5. We all may have a Type I lesion, it is basically just fraying and degeneration of the labrum.

Be sure to visit AdvancedCEU.com for more information and education DVDs, CDs, and webinars.  Interested in training or rehabilitating the shoulder?  Then check out my 4-DVD set on Optimal Shoulder Performance.

 

 

Image via Wikipedia

Opt In Image
Learn More From Mike!
Subscribe to my newsletter now and get these 3 FREE bonuses:
  • My new 1 hour+ webinar "5 Things You Need to Understand to Master Functional Rehab and Performance"
  • My popular 36-page eBook "Solving the Patellofemoral Mystery"
  • My Accelerated Rehab Protocol following ACL Reconstruction

Comment on Facebook

comments

16 Responses to “What Exactly Is a SLAP Lesion? Top 5 Things You Need to Know About a Superior Labral Tear”

  1. Good information on the SLAP Tear.

  2. Hi, I had a fall in November 2010, which we believe to be the source of the bilateral tears on my shoulders. One of the reports stats a possible SLAP lesion *R shoulder) but not on the left. I do not want surgery as I am an attorney and our livelihood requires me to be at the computer a lot. My question however is about pain levels. I have not only severe pain not only in my shoulders, but also knees, ankles, cramps in feet and legs. My osteopath says there is nothing structurally to account for the level of pain. Bloodwork for infection appears normal, inflammation levels being tested now. Do you see this sometimes? I have been put on large dose of ciproflaxin with no effect. Any suggestions welcomed.

    • Dorothy,
      This may or may not help, but if you are on the computer a lot you are likely sitting a large amount of your day. Our bodies were designed to move all day and if we don’t, we are likely hurt. Maybe a number of short walks a day will provide you relief. It will hurt at first but as your body gets use to it your joints should thank you. Consider checking out the web site http://www.juststand.org to discover more pressing reasons to get up a move more even if you actually regularly exercise. Hope this is of some help to you Dorothy. Sincerely, Priscilla

  3. I am no doctor, but you guys have no idea what you are talking about. I seen about twenty different doctors, and some of the best doctor’s in the region, none of them were able to pick it up, one did pick up the injury, thank fully. You said that a SLAP 1 does not need surgery, I just had surgery for that, and I had it for 3 years, let me tell you, it is painful as hell, and I am still in pain till now/ Maybe you guys should listen to the patients a bit more, because ultimately they would know more about their bodies than the doctors in most cases.

    • Eric,
      In regards to your comment I will say I understand your frustration but at the same time there are a lot of people walking around with disorders that do not require surgery. Meniscus tears, rotator cuff tears and yes labral tears. It all depends on the severity of the tear and how much it affects your personal daily life. If your an active person or manual laborer yes you might require surgery. If you have a sedentary job and can alleviate a majority of your symptoms with basic exercises and education, surgery can be avoided. Every patient is different and its not “classifying patients” its just classifying tears, EVERY patient is different :) Hope this helps :)

    • I agree with you my friend about having different doctor’s and pain associated with slap tear it took a year to discover my slap tear UNBELIEVABLE

  4. SLAP tear extending posterior and anterior to the bicipital anchor, as well as possible extension into the bicipital anchor. There is normal variant cleft versus anterior extension of tear into anterior superior labrum. This is my diagnosis. I am a CNA. Can you tell me what classification this is and if it requires surgery?

  5. I had a MRI Arthrogram on my left shoulder due to a work accident and in the findings they said. “Extensive slap tear of the superior labrum. The tear extends both anteriorly and posteriorly beneath the biceps Labral anchor. Anteriorly, the tear extends to the equator. Posteriorly, the tear ends at the posterior superior Labral margin.”

    Does this require surgery to fix?

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Healthy Shoulders with Terrible MRIs? | Eric Cressey - January 17, 2011

    [...] Do you train loads of overhead throwing athletes (especially pitchers) like I do?  Miniaci et al. found that 79% of asymptomatic professional pitchers (28/40) had “abnormal labrum” features and noted that “magnetic resonance imaging of the shoulder in asymptomatic high performance throwing athletes reveals abnormalities that may encompass a spectrum of ‘nonclinical’ findings.”  Yes, you can have a torn labrum and not be in pain (it depends on the kind of labral tear you have; for more information, check out Mike Reinold’s great series on SLAP lesions, starting with Part 1). [...]

  2. Back Squatting with a Posterior Labral Tear? | Eric Cressey - January 17, 2011

    [...] Top 5 Things You Need to Know about a Superior Labral Tear Clinical Examination of Superior Labral Tears [...]

  3. SLAP Tear hits close to home - August 13, 2011

    [...] What Exactly Is a SLAP Lesion? Top 5 Things You Need to Know About a Superior Labral Tear [...]

  4. Is a Biceps Tenodesis the Answer? — Encinitas Chiropractor - Vahl Chiropractic - October 27, 2012

    [...] covered superior labral tears, or SLAP tears extensively in the past. If you don’t know much about SLAP tears, start there, but essentially a [...]

  5. Inspired Fit Strong – 48 Things Worth Reading - December 28, 2012

    [...] What Exactly Is SLAP Lesion [...]

  6. Inspired Fit Strong – 51 неща, които си заслужава да прочетете - December 28, 2012

    [...] What Exactly Is SLAP Lesion [...]

  7. slap lesion physical therapy | Health Wealth Builder - June 21, 2013

    [...] What Exactly Is a SLAP Lesion? Top 5 Things You Need to Know About … [...]

  8. The Weeknd Links | benny chadwick - May 2, 2014

    […] Reinold and Eric Cressey go over the basics of SLAP lesions and shoulder […]

Leave a Reply